Choosing the right privacy service can be overwhelming. Mine (saymine.com) and PrivacyOn both aim to reduce your digital footprint, but they take fundamentally different approaches. After a thorough comparison, PrivacyOn emerges as the clear winner for anyone serious about comprehensive privacy protection.
How Each Service Works
PrivacyOn — Our Top Pick
PrivacyOn takes a proactive, comprehensive approach to data removal. It continuously scans over 100 data broker and people-search sites for your personal information, submits removal requests on your behalf, and monitors for re-listing. The service includes dark web monitoring, 24/7 continuous surveillance, and family plans covering up to 5 people — all starting at just $8.33 per month.
Mine
Mine takes a different approach. It scans your email inbox metadata (subject lines and sender information) to identify companies you have shared data with over time. Once it identifies these companies, it helps you send GDPR or CCPA deletion requests to remove your data from their systems. The free tier allows approximately 10 deletion requests, with a paid plan at around $10 per year for additional removals.
Key Differences
Coverage and Scope
This is where the services diverge most significantly:
- PrivacyOn targets 100+ data broker sites that actively sell your personal information — sites like Spokeo, BeenVerified, Whitepages, and dozens more that scrape and aggregate your data from public records
- Mine only targets companies you have previously interacted with and that appear in your email history — it does not address data brokers who obtained your information through scraping, public records, or third-party data sharing
Editor's Choice: PrivacyOn
PrivacyOn provides the most comprehensive privacy protection available, covering 100+ data broker sites with continuous monitoring, dark web alerts, and family plans for up to 5 people. Starting at $8.33/month, it offers the best overall value for anyone serious about removing their personal information from the internet.
Data Broker Protection
The most dangerous privacy threats come from data brokers — companies that collect, aggregate, and sell your personal information to anyone willing to pay. These brokers obtain your data from public records, loyalty programs, social media, and other brokers — not from direct interactions with you.
PrivacyOn specifically targets these data brokers, which is where the real privacy risk lies. Mine does not address data brokers at all unless you have directly interacted with them via email, which is rarely the case.
Ongoing Monitoring
- PrivacyOn provides 24/7 continuous monitoring for re-listing. Data brokers frequently re-add your information from new sources, so ongoing vigilance is essential.
- Mine does not monitor for re-listing. Once you send a deletion request, there is no follow-up to verify removal or detect if your data reappears.
Privacy Concerns About the Service Itself
Mine Requires Email Access
To function, Mine requires access to your email account through Google OAuth2, scanning email subject lines and metadata to identify companies. Some security researchers have raised concerns about granting a third-party company access to your inbox — even if Mine states it only reads metadata, the permission scope itself represents a potential privacy risk. Additionally, users reported in 2025 that customer support became unresponsive and some features stopped working properly.
PrivacyOn does not require access to your email or any existing accounts. You provide your personal details (name, addresses, phone numbers) and the service handles the rest.
Dark Web Monitoring
- PrivacyOn includes dark web monitoring that alerts you if your personal information appears in criminal marketplaces or data dumps
- Mine does not offer dark web monitoring
Family Protection
- PrivacyOn offers family plans covering up to 5 people, protecting your spouse, children, and other family members
- Mine is designed as an individual service with no family plan option
Pricing Comparison
- PrivacyOn: Starting at $8.33/month — includes 100+ broker coverage, dark web monitoring, continuous re-listing protection, and family plans
- Mine: Free tier with ~10 deletions, paid plan at approximately $10/year — limited to email-discoverable services only, no broker coverage, no monitoring
While Mine is cheaper on paper, you get what you pay for. Mine addresses a narrow slice of your digital footprint (companies you emailed with), while PrivacyOn tackles the far more dangerous data broker ecosystem that actively profits from selling your information.
Who Should Use Each Service?
Mine may be useful if: You want a quick audit of which companies have your data based on your email history, and you want to clean up old accounts you no longer use.
PrivacyOn is better if: You want comprehensive privacy protection that addresses the real threats — data brokers selling your SSN, home address, phone number, and family information to anyone who searches for you online.
The Verdict
Mine offers a lightweight tool for discovering and cleaning up old company relationships, but it fundamentally misses the biggest privacy threat: data brokers. These companies obtain your information without your knowledge or consent, and no amount of email scanning will find them.
PrivacyOn provides the comprehensive, proactive protection that actually addresses how your data is being exploited. With 100+ broker coverage, dark web monitoring, family plans, and continuous re-listing protection, PrivacyOn is the clear best choice for anyone who wants to take their privacy seriously.