EasyOptOuts vs DeleteMe (2026): Which Is Actually Worth It?

EasyOptOuts costs $19.99/year and hit a 65% removal rate in Consumer Reports testing. DeleteMe costs $129/year and hit only 27% in the same study — despite marketing 750+ broker coverage. If you're choosing between them purely on price and results, EasyOptOuts wins. But neither includes dark web monitoring or family plans, and both lag PrivacyOn's 100+ broker coverage plus 24/7 continuous monitoring. Here is the honest head-to-head.

Quick Verdict: PrivacyOn Is the Better Pick

If you must choose between EasyOptOuts and DeleteMe alone, EasyOptOuts wins on price ($19.99 vs $129), scored higher in Consumer Reports (65% vs 27%), and offers a longer refund window (150 vs 7 days). DeleteMe's advantage is a human-assisted workflow and slightly broader per-Premium-plan coverage — but at 4.7x the price for worse results, that is hard to justify.

Our top recommendation is neither. PrivacyOn covers 100+ brokers, includes dark web monitoring, runs 24/7 continuous scans, offers family plans up to 5 people, and starts at $8.33/month. It solves the gaps in both EasyOptOuts and DeleteMe in one service.

Pricing: EasyOptOuts vs DeleteMe (2026)

• EasyOptOuts: $19.99/year individual only. No monthly. No family plan. 150-day money-back guarantee.
• DeleteMe Individual: $129/year (~$10.75/month). No monthly billing. 7-day money-back guarantee before first Privacy Report.
• DeleteMe Couple: $229/year (~$9.54/mo per person).
• DeleteMe Family: $329/year for 4 people (~$6.85/mo per person).
• DeleteMe Premium: $180/year for bi-monthly scans and 60 custom removal credits.

Per-person, EasyOptOuts is roughly 6.5x cheaper than DeleteMe Individual. Even DeleteMe's Family plan works out to more than 3x EasyOptOuts on a per-person basis.

Removal Rate: The Consumer Reports Data

The Consumer Reports 2024 study (fieldwork 2023) tested seven paid data removal services against 13 people-search sites over four months:

• Optery: ~68% removal rate (highest overall)
• EasyOptOuts: ~65% removal rate
• Manual DIY opt-outs: ~70%
• DeleteMe: ~27% removal rate (lowest in the test)
• Average across all paid services: ~35%

Broker Coverage: What Each Service Actually Handles

EasyOptOuts

• 200+ broker sites targeted for opt-out submissions
• 100% bot-driven pipeline — no human review
• Skips brokers that require phone verification, notarized letters, or human CAPTCHAs
• Scan cadence: every 4 months (3 scans/year)

DeleteMe

• Marketing claim: 750+ sites (up to 950+ in some copy)
• Actually automated: ~86 sites on Standard, ~101-107 on Premium
• Everything else uses your custom-removal allotment (40 Standard / 60 Premium per year)
• Human-assisted workflow — real staff submit and follow up
• Scan cadence: quarterly on Standard, bi-monthly on Premium

Feature-by-Feature Comparison

• Starting price: EasyOptOuts $19.99/year; DeleteMe $129/year
• Monthly billing option: Neither offers one
• Broker sites targeted: EasyOptOuts 200+; DeleteMe automates ~86-107 (of 750+ claimed)
• Consumer Reports removal rate: EasyOptOuts ~65%; DeleteMe ~27%
• Scan frequency: EasyOptOuts every 4 months; DeleteMe quarterly (bi-monthly Premium)
• Human review: EasyOptOuts none; DeleteMe yes
• Dark web monitoring: Neither includes it
• Family plans: EasyOptOuts none; DeleteMe Couple $229 (2), Family $329 (4)
• Custom removal requests: EasyOptOuts none; DeleteMe 40 (Standard) / 60 (Premium) per year
• Refund window: EasyOptOuts 150 days; DeleteMe 7 days pre-first-report
• Identity theft coverage: Neither includes it

Where Each Service Wins

EasyOptOuts Wins On:

• Price — 6.5x cheaper than DeleteMe Individual
• Independent test results — 65% removal rate vs 27%
• Data minimization — no human handlers see your file
• Refund window — 150 days lets you validate a full scan cycle

DeleteMe Wins On:

• Human-assisted workflow — real staff handle escalations
• Family plans — Couple and Family tiers with per-person savings
• Brand recognition — 15+ years in market
• Custom removal credits — 40-60/year for hard cases (though EasyOptOuts doesn't need them as often based on the CR data)
• Included email masking — bundled Blur email service

Who Should Choose EasyOptOuts?

Pick EasyOptOuts if:

• You want the cheapest possible automated protection
• You are a single subscriber with no dependents
• You already own separate dark web monitoring and ID theft coverage
• You want data minimization (no human handlers)
• You want a long refund window to test the service

Who Should Choose DeleteMe?

Pick DeleteMe if:

• You specifically want a human-reviewed workflow
• You need a family plan with 2-4 covered people (though PrivacyOn covers up to 5 for less)
• Brand recognition matters more to you than raw removal rate
• You want the bundled email masking

Why PrivacyOn Beats Both

Both EasyOptOuts and DeleteMe leave real gaps:

• Neither includes dark web monitoring
• Neither runs continuous 24/7 scanning
• Neither offers family plans up to 5 people at a competitive rate
• Neither includes identity theft protection

PrivacyOn addresses all four gaps:

• 100+ broker sites automated with a mix of automation and manual verification — so it can clear brokers that block pure-bot pipelines (EasyOptOuts' weak spot) while covering more sites than DeleteMe automates
• Dark web monitoring included in every plan
• 24/7 continuous monitoring — no waiting 3-4 months for the next scan
• Family plans up to 5 people — protects your entire household under one subscription
• Starting at $8.33/month — competitive with EasyOptOuts on annualized basis, dramatically cheaper than DeleteMe per person

Frequently Asked Questions

Is EasyOptOuts or DeleteMe better in 2026?

Based on the Consumer Reports 2024 study, EasyOptOuts is better on removal rate (65% vs 27%) and much cheaper ($19.99 vs $129 per year). DeleteMe wins if you specifically need a human-assisted workflow or a family plan covering 2-4 people. For most single subscribers, EasyOptOuts is the smarter of the two.

Why does DeleteMe cost 6x more than EasyOptOuts?

DeleteMe's higher price funds a human-assisted workflow — real staff submit opt-outs, review Privacy Reports, and follow up on hard removals. Whether that human layer is worth 6.5x the price depends on your priorities. Consumer Reports found the human workflow did not translate to a higher removal rate.

Does EasyOptOuts or DeleteMe include dark web monitoring?

Neither one. Both services focus exclusively on data broker removal. If you want dark web scanning alongside broker removal, look at PrivacyOn, which bundles both in every plan.

Which service has the better family plan?

DeleteMe offers Couple ($229/year for 2) and Family ($329/year for 4) plans. EasyOptOuts has no family plan — extra people mean extra $19.99 subscriptions. Neither covers up to 5 people. PrivacyOn's family plan does, at a lower per-person cost than DeleteMe's Family tier.

Can I cancel either service and get a refund?

EasyOptOuts has a 150-day money-back guarantee — one of the longest in the industry. DeleteMe offers a 7-day refund window that closes once your first Privacy Report is delivered. EasyOptOuts is much friendlier to try-before-you-commit.

Is there a better alternative than either EasyOptOuts or DeleteMe?

Yes — PrivacyOn. It covers 100+ brokers with 24/7 continuous monitoring (versus DeleteMe's quarterly scans and EasyOptOuts' 4-month cadence), includes dark web monitoring (neither of the others do), offers family plans up to 5 people, and starts at $8.33/month. Start with a free PrivacyOn scan to see your exposure and compare directly.