PrivacyOn vs Optery
Optery's free exposure report and $39 Core tier make it the best cheap self-serve option for one person; PrivacyOn is the better overall pick because one plan includes what Optery charges $149 to $249 per person for, families pay a flat rate instead of per seat, and we publish how brokers actually respond.
Our pick
Choose PrivacyOn if…
- You are protecting two or more people (Optery charges per person)
- You want follow-up on silent brokers without a $149-per-person tier
- You want dark web and password-leak alerts included
- You live in the UK or EU (Optery does not serve them)
Fair play
Choose Optery if…
- You want a free, screenshot-backed exposure report and will do removals yourself
- You are one person and $39/yr for fully automated removal is the budget
- You want the largest advertised site count (630+ on Ultimate) and will pay $249/yr for it
- You live in Australia, New Zealand or South Africa
Optery is the most tiered product in this category, and that is both its strength and its catch. As of October 2026 it offers a genuinely useful free tier (an exposure report with screenshots and self-serve opt-out tools), then Core at $39/yr (380+ sites, fully automated), Extended at $149/yr (555+ sites, a human privacy agent, quarterly screenshot reports) and Ultimate at $249/yr (630+ sites and unlimited custom removals). Every price is per person; there is no bundled couple or family rate on the pricing page.
PrivacyOn sells one plan at $99.95/yr for one person ($8.33/mo, or $7.08/mo on a two-year term), $164.95/yr for two and $229.95/yr for up to five, and it includes follow-up and escalation when a broker goes silent, which Optery reserves for its human-agent tiers, plus dark web monitoring and an encrypted Vault Optery does not offer at any price. If you are one person on a strict budget, Optery Core is a fair buy. For everyone else, and for anyone who wants to see how brokers really respond, PrivacyOn is the pick.
PrivacyOn vs Optery at a glance
| Compare | PrivacyOn | Optery |
|---|---|---|
| Price, one person (annual) | $99.95/yr ($8.33/mo); $7.08/mo on two-year; $29/mo monthly | Free (self-serve); Core $39/yr; Extended $149/yr; Ultimate $249/yr; monthly $3.99 to $24.99 |
| Brokers covered | 100+ data broker and people-search sites, re-scanned continuously | 380+ (Core), 555+ (Extended), 630+ (Ultimate), plus custom requests on Ultimate |
| Family plan | Up to 5 people, $229.95/yr | None shown; each person pays their own tier (5 x Ultimate = $1,245/yr) |
| Monitoring | Continuous re-scans and re-removal, dark web and leaked-password alerts | Monthly automated scans and removals; no dark web monitoring |
| International / GDPR | US plus our own GDPR and UK GDPR lane | US, Canada (excl. Quebec), Australia, New Zealand, South Africa; no UK or EU consumer service |
| Guarantee | 30-day money-back; free scan first | 30-day money-back on paid tiers |
| Proof of removal | Per-broker status in your dashboard, plus a public Data Broker Response Report showing how brokers actually answer our requests | Exposure report with screenshots (free); quarterly removal reports with screenshots on Extended and Ultimate |
Optery figures as of October 12, 2026, from: optery.com/pricing (Free, Core, Extended, Ultimate; site counts; 30-day guarantee); help.optery.com, "Does Optery work in other countries". Check their site for current offers. PrivacyOn prices are from our own checkout.
01
Pricing: four per-person tiers vs one flat plan
Optery's pricing as of October 2026: Free Basic (exposure report, self-serve tools), Core at $3.99/mo or $39/yr, Extended at $14.99/mo or $149/yr, and Ultimate at $24.99/mo or $249/yr, all per person with a 30-day money-back guarantee. Core is fully automated with no human review and one name variation; Extended adds a human privacy agent, unlimited name variations and quarterly reports with screenshots; Ultimate adds unlimited custom removal requests. The pricing page shows no household bundle, so two people on Extended pay $298 and five people on Ultimate pay $1,245 a year.
PrivacyOn's one plan costs $29/mo, $99.95/yr or $169.95 per two years for one person; $49/mo / $164.95/yr / $280.95 for two; $69/mo / $229.95/yr / $390.95 per two years for up to five. Follow-up on unanswered requests is included, as are dark web alerts and the Vault. Against Optery Extended, which is the closest like-for-like tier, one person saves about $49 a year; a couple saves about $133; a family of five saves about $515 against five Extended seats and over $1,000 against five Ultimate seats.
Where Optery wins on price: Core at $39 is less than half our annual rate for one person, if you are happy with automation only and 380+ sites. Our Optery cost breakdown walks through each tier; the pricing page has the per-month table.
02
Coverage: Optery's site counts are the largest here, at the top tier
Optery advertises the highest site counts in this comparison: 380+ on Core, 555+ on Extended and 630+ on Ultimate, with "expanded reach" to further sites on the upper tiers. Its free exposure report, which screenshots your actual profiles, is the best no-cost way to see your exposure that any vendor offers, and we recommend running it even if you end up buying PrivacyOn.
PrivacyOn covers 100+ data broker and people-search sites and also starts with a free exposure scan. The difference is in what happens next: we re-scan the covered sites continuously and re-file when you reappear, and our paid plan includes follow-up and escalation of unanswered requests, which Optery sells only on Extended and Ultimate. We also cover the marketing-data brokers behind spam lists, which rarely show a searchable profile but are where phone and email data is traded.
If raw site count at any price is your metric, Optery Ultimate at $249 per person is the number to beat. If you want verified status across the sites that expose you, with family cover, PrivacyOn's model costs a fraction as much.
03
How removals actually work: screenshots are good, reply data is better
Most comparison pages stop at site counts. The number that matters more is what happens after a request is sent, and that is where PrivacyOn publishes something nobody else in this comparison does. Our Data Broker Response Report is recomputed daily from our own removal system. As of 12 October 2026 it covers 621 authorized-agent requests sent to 75 brokers. Only 22% had received any reply; 46% of first replies were nothing more than an auto-acknowledgement; 29% of substantive replies told us to go and fill in a web form instead; and 59% of requests old enough to measure were still unanswered after 14 days. Where a broker did confirm deletion, the median time from request to confirmation was about 42 hours (a small sample of 14 so far, which we flag on the report itself).
We publish this because it changes how you should judge any removal service, including ours. A broker that never replies has not removed anything, however many "requests sent" a dashboard shows. So PrivacyOn pairs every request with re-scans of the broker site itself and re-files when your listing reappears, and the dashboard tells you which brokers confirmed, which went quiet, and which need a step only you can complete (identity checks and web forms that legally require the data subject). We also measure the other side of the problem: 36% of our automated people-search scans in the last 30 days were blocked by CAPTCHAs or IP bans, which is why "monitoring" claims from any vendor deserve scepticism.
To Optery's credit, its screenshot-based reports are a real form of proof: a before-and-after image of your profile on a site is evidence most vendors do not provide, and on Extended and Ultimate you get them quarterly. What Optery does not publish is the aggregate reply rate or time to confirmation across its requests. We think customers deserve both, which is why PrivacyOn shows per-broker status in the dashboard and publishes the aggregate numbers daily.
04
International customers: Optery goes south, PrivacyOn goes to Europe
Per Optery's help centre as of October 2026, consumer accounts are available to residents of the US, Canada (excluding Quebec), Australia, New Zealand and South Africa. If you are in one of those countries outside North America, Optery is one of very few options and PrivacyOn does not currently serve you.
PrivacyOn serves the US and runs its own GDPR and UK GDPR lane for UK and EU customers, drafting Article 17 erasure requests, tracking the one-month deadline and escalating silence. Those requests appear in the same Response Report as our US requests. If you are in the UK or EU, Optery is not an option and PrivacyOn is our recommendation.
05
Support, guarantees and the self-serve question
Both services offer a 30-day money-back guarantee on paid plans. Optery's free tier means you can also stay unpaid indefinitely and do the work yourself, which is a legitimate path if you have the time: our own data shows 19% of steps that legally require the individual have been completed by customers so far, which gives a sense of how much self-serve work people actually finish.
PrivacyOn support is by email with a per-member dashboard and a guided list of the steps only you can complete. Optery offers email support on paid tiers and priority support on Ultimate. Neither is phone-first; if you want a phone line, look at DeleteMe or Aura instead (PrivacyOn vs DeleteMe, PrivacyOn vs Aura).
06
Who should pick which
Pick Optery if you are one person who wants the free exposure report and is willing to do removals yourself, if $39 a year for automated-only removal is your ceiling, if you want the largest advertised site count and will pay $249 for it, or if you live in Australia, New Zealand or South Africa.
Pick PrivacyOn if you are protecting more than one person, want follow-up on silent brokers without a $149 to $249 per-person tier, want dark web monitoring and a Vault included, live in the UK or EU, or want published response data rather than a site count. Our wider roundup is at best data removal services 2026 and we also cover Optery alternatives.
The verdict
PrivacyOn or Optery?
PrivacyOn is the better overall choice. Optery's free report is excellent and Core is the cheapest automated removal here, and if you are a single person on a budget it is a fair alternative. But the moment you want follow-up on silent brokers, a second person on the account or monitoring beyond brokers, Optery's per-seat tiers climb fast while PrivacyOn's one plan already includes them. Run both free scans; then compare what a year actually costs for your household.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Optery cheaper than PrivacyOn?
Only at the bottom tier. Optery Core is $39/yr per person for fully automated removal with no human review, against PrivacyOn's $99.95/yr (or $7.08/mo on two years). Optery's Extended ($149) and Ultimate ($249) tiers, which add the human agent and custom requests PrivacyOn includes, cost more per person. For most households we recommend PrivacyOn.
Does Optery have a family plan?
Optery's pricing page shows no bundled couple or family rate as of October 2026; each person pays their own tier, so a family of five on Ultimate is $1,245/yr. PrivacyOn's Family plan covers up to five people for $229.95/yr with dark web monitoring included, which makes it our clear recommendation for households.
Does Optery cover more sites than PrivacyOn?
Optery advertises more: 380+ on Core, 555+ on Extended and 630+ on Ultimate. PrivacyOn covers 100+ data broker and people-search sites, re-scans them continuously and publishes how brokers respond. If headline count at any price matters most, Optery Ultimate leads; for verified status and value we recommend PrivacyOn.
Is Optery's free plan worth using?
Yes. Optery's free exposure report with screenshots is one of the best no-cost tools available, and we suggest running it alongside PrivacyOn's free scan. The free tier gives you self-serve opt-out tools but no automated removal; if you want someone to do the work and keep doing it, PrivacyOn's single plan is our pick.
Can I use Optery or PrivacyOn in the UK or EU?
Optery serves the US, Canada (excluding Quebec), Australia, New Zealand and South Africa, not the UK or EU. PrivacyOn serves the US and runs its own GDPR and UK GDPR removal lane for UK and EU residents, so for European customers PrivacyOn is the recommendation by default.
Keep comparing
- PrivacyOn vs Incogni
- PrivacyOn vs DeleteMe
- PrivacyOn vs Aura
- Optery pricing: the full 2026 cost breakdown
- Optery alternatives for 2026
- The best data removal services of 2026
- PrivacyOn pricing and plans
- Data Broker Response Report (live)
Other comparisons: PrivacyOn vs Incogni, PrivacyOn vs DeleteMe, PrivacyOn vs Aura. Live exposure numbers: data broker statistics.